Monday, November 28, 2016

Enterprise S4E10 Daedalus

Dr. Emory Erickson, inventor of the transporter, conducts a long-range experiment in order to recover his lost son – Wikipedia.

The good:

It’s cool to meet early pioneers in critical Starfleet technology. Transporters are a big deal. In particular, I loved the discussion on early competition between warp drive and transporter technology. Which one is actually better? There isn’t always a clear “right” answer at the beginning.

On a related note, these technologies were inherently dangerous and even unpredictable in the developmental stages. Of course, transporter malfunctions are a staple of Star Trek, but it makes sense. Transporters are freakin’ weird and scary if you think about it.

Emerson’s nod to the moral/philosophical arguments of transporter technology and the nature of the human soul. Of course, he only brought it up to immediately dismiss it – no time to go down that rabbit hole. Read more about it here.

Nice character development with Archer and Danica.

Great job on including the Kir’Shara – T’Pol was reading Surak in the mess hall. The Kir’Shara is a cultural bombshell – and logically it’s what all the cool Vulcans will be reading for quite some time. I was fairly certain that it was going to be an immediate throwaway despite being the focus of a three-episode arc.

Quinn’s radiation ghost looked pretty cool.

The bad:

Poor Tucker! He just wanted to hang out with his childhood hero. He was totally star struck. It was going to be one of the highlights of his life. And Emerson just took a crap on him the whole time. It’s good to have characters that are flawed and unlikable…still felt bad for the guy.


Very straightforward and forgettable bottle episode.

Friday, November 25, 2016

Enterprise S4E7-9 The Forge...of Boredom

S4E7 The Forge - Earth's embassy on Vulcan is partially destroyed by a bomb, killing Admiral Forrest. Archer & T'Pol travel to Vulcan in search of an alleged terrorist group blamed for the explosion, of which T'Pol's mother is s member.

S4E8 Awakening - Archer & T'Pol find T'Pau and T'Pol's mother and learn that Archer is carrying Surak'skatra.

S4E9 Kir'Shara - Archer and T'Pol bring back the Kir'Shara (Surek's artifact) that will lead changes in the Vulcan world. T'Pol's Pa'nar Syndrome is cured by T'Pau.

The good:

It was cool to see planet Vulcan.

Introduction of the katra.

T'Pol gets cured...end of a meh plot line.

The Vulcans are forced to finally get over themselves a bit.

The bad:

"T'Pol's Pa'nar Syndrome is cured by T'Pau" is perhaps the geekiest sentence I have ever written.

I don't have many plot issues. This three story arc introduced a key concept with the katra, resolved a sub-plots (T'Pol's illness and marriage), and set up a critically important development in human-Vulcan relations.

Having said that, I cannot offer specifics as to why this was so forgettable and boring. It took me a couple of months to get through these episodes. If memory serves, it took 3-4 viewing sessions to get through the Forge and at least two sessions to get through Awakening. I watched Kir'Shara immediateky following Awakening...and I fell asleep in the middle. Part of the problem was that I kept trying to watch after I went to bed...but I stay awake too late watching plenty of other shows. It was just a snooze-fest (literally).

I don't even have any pithy remarks, just glad to move on.