Friday, December 20, 2013

Enterprise S1E15 - Shuttlepod One

Reed and Trip are stranded in a shuttlepod with no foreseeable help arriving before life support runs out - Wikipedia

The good:

Hmmm…this was a very middle of the road episode for me. I feel like the shuttle pod episodes (I have a vague memory of two or three from TNG) are always like that. Don’t get me wrong, I can totally appreciate minimalist sets to focus on character, but frankly, the script and the acting have to be top notch to pull it off. I did liked more as it went on, but basically that meant I went from active dislike to bland detachment.

This was the first character building episode for Malcolm where I actually felt a bit of a connection.

The end scene “Am I still dreaming” thing between Malcom and T’Pol was decent (but in no way balanced out the painful set up – see below)

Basically, there was some payoff in this episode, but there was a lot of crap to wade through. Just watch the last ten minutes or so and call it a night.

The bad:

Mashed potatoes to seal a pressure leak? Nope.

How convenient that Archer had a bottle of liquor stowed in the shuttlepod.
                                                                                                                    
The dream rescue sequence between T’Pol and Malcolm was physically painful to watch. Stinky? STINKY? Seriously, I totally appreciate what they were going for, but a swing and miss.

No comments:

Post a Comment